rod vs reel

otoshi · #1 31-10-2013, 04:27 AM

just out to seek some option on which of the above a fellow fisho see as more important and willing to spend more coins over the other.

unconsciously, my set up have always been reel over rod. maybe coz i find that a smooth drag and a system that is strong and reliable is more important over the "stick" so... all points of view welcome.

JIM1 · #2 31-10-2013, 04:39 AM

About the same, I wound out a cheap reel on a expensive rod or vise versa. Currently reels outway my rods by about 20% at a guess

Nix88 · #3 31-10-2013, 04:51 AM

Both are equally important

Partizan Fk · #4 31-10-2013, 04:56 AM

I think both are important.You dont need to kill the wallet to balance out both

spork · #5 31-10-2013, 04:57 AM

Looking at my gear, I've spend more on reels than rods.
This doesn't mean I think the reel is more important, it's just a more complicated item and I guess it costs more to manufacture a "good" reel than it does a "good" rod.
Also "value" doesn't always = cost here.
I have cheaper rods that have lasted a decade or 2, and will probably last a couple more. Pretty simple things, few moving parts, no bearings to rust. "Cheap" reels do not last that long, and can become expensive if you have to keep replacing them.

Having a rod builder as a sponsor probably helps too.

If I could buy reels @ cost price the equation might be different.

Apache · #6 31-10-2013, 05:49 AM

With my purest hat on: the rod is more important than the reel. With a great rod you'd have better ability to trick your target fish with technique. You won't catch anymore fish with a super reel but you would with a super rod.
But with my self-gratifying hat: using a great reel is like as close as you'd ever get to fondling with Miranda Kerr.

TheChief · #7 31-10-2013, 05:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Apache

With my purest hat on: the rod is more important than the reel. With a great rod you'd have better ability to trick your target fish with technique. You won't catch anymore fish with a super reel but you would with a super rod.
But with my self-gratifying hat: using a great reel is like as close as you'd ever get to fondling with Miranda Kerr.

HAHA well said!

Abuthen · #8 31-10-2013, 05:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Apache

But with my self-gratifying hat: using a great reel is like as close as you'd ever get to fondling with Miranda Kerr.

You're gonna have to let me have a go at that reel one day...

Apache · #9 31-10-2013, 06:11 AM

Miranda Kerr is off limits but I have a few Lara Bingles that you're welcome to. My sacred reels are locked up in glass display.

FishoStu · #10 31-10-2013, 06:37 AM

Rod without doubt in my view.
(having said that the reels I use cost more than double what my rods cost...lol )

otoshi · #11 31-10-2013, 06:50 AM

sounds like rod is on the winning end but due to that reel cost more... therefore everyone is spending more coins on their reel?

FishoStu · #12 31-10-2013, 07:04 AM

To be honest I think the rods these days are of such quality you can get some very nice specimens for very fair prices.
You get some great second hand deals from sites such as this & I find that is a great way to get decent gear without breaking the bank.
Also I buy my reels thinking they should last for a very long time but rods I think have a shorter lifespan as a rule simply to being a little more susceptible to damage.

Muz11 · #13 31-10-2013, 07:16 AM

IMO;

50% rod

20% reel

30% line.

Your rod and your line are the connection between you and the artificial bait your using. If you can feel any little bump or touch on your lure then you know what is happening on the other end, meaning you can catch more fish.

The reel is primarily to bring the fish in, this is where a good drag system is paramount. The drag on a low end reel can be tricked or customised to perform better.

Just my thoughts.

TheChief · #14 31-10-2013, 07:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by otoshi

sounds like rod is on the winning end but due to that reel cost more... therefore everyone is spending more coins on their reel?

I probably have been but not because my rods are cheap as such.... My reels just are more expensive!

I'd recommend you spend more on the rod if you are trying budget on what to buy next. If cash isn't a issue spent up big on both...

otoshi · #15 31-10-2013, 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheChief

I probably have been but not because my rods are cheap as such.... My reels just are more expensive!

I'd recommend you spend more on the rod if you are trying budget on what to buy next. If cash isn't a issue spent up big on both...

me with VERY shallow pocket Chief... but keen to get the best of both worlds. therefore seeking all available advice from all the masters here on BM.